1 Chronicles 10:6 tells us this about the death of Saul:
On the other hand, 2 Samuel 2:8 tells us of a surviving son:
This certainly looks like a problem. The verse in 1 Chronicles seems to imply that Saul's whole family died in the battle, while 2 Samuel disagrees. However, there's another description of those events that is worth looking at, 1 Samuel 31:2:
By actually naming the sons of Saul that died, this passage does a lot to resolve the problem. It's clear that Ish-bosheth is not among the dead. Presumably, Saul had a son not present at the battle, and 1 Chronicles is only telling us about those who were there.
There's still the problem that "all [Saul's] house died together". This might seem to imply his entire family. If taken literally though, "his house" could simply mean those who actually lived with him.
Back to errancy.org main index